For police officers and firefighters
DROP & Deferred Comp: What to Know Before You Retire
Your DROP and your deferred comp may be the most money you’ll ever have in one place. The choices you make in the first year can follow you for the next thirty.
“Why didn’t anyone tell us about this? I wouldn’t have made these mistakes.”
The number one thing I hear from retired police officers and firefighters.
The three pieces most of you have
- Your pension: a paycheck for life.
- Your DROP (Deferred Retirement Option Program): once you’re eligible to retire, your pension is locked in and the monthly checks go into a DROP account while you keep working for a set number of years. When you leave, it’s paid out, usually as one big lump sum.
- Your deferred comp (457(b)): the money you put in from every paycheck. It’s the government’s version of a 401(k), with one big difference most people don’t know about.
5 mistakes I see police officers and firefighters make
1. Rolling everything into an IRA too soon
A governmental 457(b) has no 10% penalty on withdrawals after you leave the job, at any age. And under the public safety exception, if you leave in or after the year you turn 50, or after 25 years of service, money taken straight from your government plan may also skip the penalty. Roll it all into an IRA and both protections are gone. Need $40,000 at 52? From deferred comp, you pay income tax. From an IRA, you pay income tax plus a $4,000 penalty.
2. Treating your DROP like a lotto payout
A check made out to you has 20% withheld for federal tax, and one big lump sum can push you into a higher tax bracket. In some plans, if you don’t pick a payout option by the deadline, you get the lump sum by default.
3. Retiring with no plan
How much monthly income you need, health insurance until Medicare at 65, which pension option protects your spouse, your beneficiary forms, and taxes. Two things people miss: up to $3,000 a year from your plan may be tax-free when it pays health insurance premiums, and many plans let final sick and vacation payouts go into deferred comp if you set it up before your last paycheck.
4. Full market risk right after you retire
A crash in your first year or two does far more damage than the same crash ten years later, because you’re taking money out while it’s down.
5. Thinking your plan’s options are your only options
Plan options usually come through one or two companies. Nobody’s doing that on purpose; it’s how these plans are set up. Once you leave the job, there’s a whole open market: dozens of insurance companies, with protection and income options your plan may not offer.
How annuities can help
People use annuities for two reasons:
- Protected growth: a place for money to grow where a market drop can’t take it backwards. When the market goes up, you earn interest up to a limit. When it goes down, you don’t lose money because of that drop.
- A paycheck for life: turn the part you can’t afford to lose into income you can’t outlive, for you or for both you and your spouse. An annuity can also pay for a set number of years to bridge a gap, say until Social Security starts.
Some plans even let you take your DROP as an annuity right from the plan. Money you’ll need before 59½ usually stays where it is. An annuity is for the money you won’t need in the next few years.
Questions police officers and firefighters ask
What is a DROP?
DROP stands for Deferred Retirement Option Program.
Once you’re eligible to retire, your pension is locked in. Instead of paying you, those monthly pension checks go into a DROP account while you keep working for a set number of years. When you leave, the account is paid out, usually as one big lump sum. Not every state or city has one, and some call it something else.
What should I do with my DROP money?
Treat it as retirement income that may need to last 30+ years, not a jackpot.
Know your plan’s payout deadline. Avoid the 20% withholding with a direct rollover. Keep the money you may need before 59½ where it is. And consider turning part of it into protected growth or a monthly paycheck.
Can I roll my DROP into an annuity?
Often yes, with a direct rollover into an annuity set up as an IRA.
With a direct rollover, nothing is withheld, and you pay tax only as income comes out. Some plans also offer an annuity payout right from the plan. Before 59½, IRA rules apply, so plan the timing carefully.
Is there a penalty on 457(b) withdrawals?
Not after you leave the job, at any age, from a governmental 457(b).
Income tax still applies. But once the money is rolled into an IRA, IRA rules take over, and the 10% penalty applies before 59½ unless an exception fits.
What is the public safety exception?
If you leave the job in or after the year you turn 50, or after 25 years of service, distributions from your government plan may avoid the 10% penalty.
It applies to money taken straight from the plan. It does not follow the money into an IRA.
Why is 20% taken out of my DROP check?
Federal law requires 20% withholding when an eligible payout is paid to you.
A direct rollover, straight from the plan to the new account, avoids the withholding.
Can I use my retirement plan to pay health insurance before 65?
Retired public safety officers may exclude up to $3,000 a year from income when plan money pays health or long-term care premiums.
Ask your plan how it handles this. It’s one of the most-missed benefits.
Should I roll my deferred comp into an IRA when I retire?
Not all of it, usually.
Keep what you may need before 59½ in the plan. The rest can be compared with options on the open market.
Are my plan’s options my only options?
No.
Inside the plan you have its menu, which usually comes through one or two companies. Once you leave the job, you can compare it with the whole open market.
What happens if I don’t choose a DROP payout option?
In some plans, you get a lump sum by default, fully taxed that year.
Check your plan’s deadline and make your choice before it passes.
For union & pension board members
Your members were the heroes in the field. Now it’s the board’s turn.
They spent 25 years running toward what everyone else runs from. The people who protect them now are the union and pension board members who make sure they leave with the best retirement possible, and every option available to them.
- Private one-on-one virtual meetings for members within a few years of retirement or DROP exit
- A short video made for your chapter or station that you can share with all of your members
- The Before-You-Retire Checklist for every member
- Education only, at no cost to the board, the union or the plan, and no changes to your plan
- Independent: not tied to your plan’s provider or any one insurance company
You’ve done the work. Now let’s build a plan you can actually retire on.
Pick a time with meEducation only. Every DROP and deferred comp plan has its own rules, so check your plan’s terms. For tax questions, talk to your CPA or tax professional.